testing matte finish tire dressings

I

imported_carclean

New member
I am testing several of the most recommended (on this site) matte tire dressings. I have learned a lot on this site, and thought I would “give back.� I put mothers reflections on two tires, AA low shine on one, and zaino z16 on another. All tires looked good. The AA had almost no shine. The tire just looked black. The other two had a slight shine, with z16 being more shinny. After a day and a half of heavy rain (heavy for Los Angeles), the mothers is completely off the tires. I can only assume that it is not waterproof. If a rain washed it off, then one or two car washes would probably take it all off. The z16 and the AA are still on the tire, with the z16 looking better. I can’t tell for sure, because it is still cloudy. The one other possibly good product I want to test is Z1 Tiefenpfleger. I had a small sample of that which I used up on my bumper and trim (Honda CRV). It is holding up well on those parts, and the tech support guy at 1z said that it is also great for tires.
 
carclean said:
The one other possibly good product I want to test is [1Z] Tiefenpfleger. I had a small sample of that which I used up on my bumper and trim (Honda CRV). It is holding up well on those parts, and the tech support guy at 1z said that it is also great for tires.
Click to expand...





1Z Tiefenfleger on tires (Bridgestone Potenza RE950)



1Z_2.JPG




1Z_tire_closeup.JPG
 
I still say Tropi-Care's dressing will last longer than anything on the market and it is water-based. I just wish you could spray it on. I will try the 1Z later this year.
 
I checked with Tropi-care, and both of their tire dressings (silicon and non-silicon) I think are both semi-gloss, if not more glossy. The non-silicon is described as the "salad oil" look. If the 1z or z16 holds up for a month, I would rather have the matte look and put that on once per month.
 
Are you going to limit your dressings to PDMS based or both varities ( PDMS and dimethyl silicone) ?





Also, regarding looks, dressings may vary from tire to tire--across brands and even models.
 
[quote name='Bill D']Are you going to limit your dressings to PDMS based or both varities ( PDMS and dimethyl silicone) ?



What does this mean? I am limiting my choice to dressings with a low, or very little shine. So long as it lasts for at least a few weeks (2 or more washings) I don't care what is in the product.
 
Z16 is my favorite. After a few applications, it seems to keep the tire dark black for long periods...even with thorough cleanings. It seems to really soak into the rubber.
 
ZaneO said:
Z16 is my favorite. After a few applications, it seems to keep the tire dark black for long periods...even with thorough cleanings. It seems to really soak into the rubber.
Click to expand...

Zaneo- how long do you wait between applications? More frequent at first?
 
SpoiledMan said:
Yep, you can shine a Michelin or Yokohama with spit!
Click to expand...

Isn't that the truth! I noticed a huge difference in the shine when I got my new michelin hydroedges a couple weeks ago.
 
carclean said:
[quote name='Bill D']Are you going to limit your dressings to PDMS based or both varities ( PDMS and dimethyl silicone) ?



What does this mean? I am limiting my choice to dressings with a low, or very little shine. So long as it lasts for at least a few weeks (2 or more washings) I don't care what is in the product.
Click to expand...





OK then, typically low to very little shine dressings are water based ( PDMS) dressings. How long they last is going to depend not only the specific product but also the type and condition ( cleanliness in particular) of the tires.
 
Bill D said:
<snip>



Also, regarding looks, dressings may vary from tire to tire--across brands and even models.
Click to expand...

They most definately do... I can vouch for that from personal experience.
 
#38 on my new Michelin Hydroedge tires. Definately more gloss on Michelin tires... I had the stock Contenential tires on with #38 and you could barely tell it was on... not the case with the new Michelin tires. I like the look of #38 :)



174_7406.jpg




174_7407.jpg
 
If you can, pick up a bottle of Mothers Reflection tire shine. I love the look, and to top it off, I got 3 bottles at Kragen for $1.99 each.
 
carclean said:
I am testing several of the most recommended (on this site) matte tire dressings. I have learned a lot on this site, and thought I would “give back.” I put mothers reflections on two tires, AA low shine on one, and zaino z16 on another. All tires looked good. The AA had almost no shine. The tire just looked black. The other two had a slight shine, with z16 being more shinny. After a day and a half of heavy rain (heavy for Los Angeles), the mothers is completely off the tires. I can only assume that it is not waterproof. If a rain washed it off, then one or two car washes would probably take it all off. The z16 and the AA are still on the tire, with the z16 looking better. I can’t tell for sure, because it is still cloudy. The one other possibly good product I want to test is Z1 Tiefenpfleger. I had a small sample of that which I used up on my bumper and trim (Honda CRV). It is holding up well on those parts, and the tech support guy at 1z said that it is also great for tires.
Click to expand...



Thanks for the feedback! As far as reflections durability, it helps if you wipe the excess after applying it ;)
 
AlexRuiz said:
Thanks for the feedback! As far as reflections durability, it helps if you wipe the excess after applying it ;)
Click to expand...

Yeah, I was thinking the same as I was reading the review.



I've noticed that with a few brands. If you apply them and walk away, they wash off in the first rain. If you wipe off the excess after an hour, it gives a more matte look and it lasts much longer.



Maybe you should redo the test on all the original brands, but this time wipe the excess off. Report back with the difference in look and durability. :xyxthumbs
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top