Well, I finally got down to my local Mini dealer for a quick spin. Unfortunately, it was less than an hour before close, but I did get a good introduction and a short test drive.
Honestly, I didn't think that the car would live up to the comments made here...and, boy, was I proved wrong! What a fun little car.
And it's really not a little car. The exterior is small at less than 12 feet and I can practically reach across the entire roof (unlike those of us Autopians that own or detail Hummers!)
"So hop in" my salesperson says, "but try the back seat first." WOW...not a limo back seat, what an incredible amount of room for such a small car. Not too bad to get in and out (and the car was parked on a fairly steep incline).
Now checking out the front seat is also pretty impressive. Probably just a smidgen less side-to-side room when compared to my Jetta, but the fore/aft spacing is comfortable. There's a decent mount of headroom, too.
Everything about the car is real BMW-like (naturally, considering its parentage). Nice thud to the door when it closes and all the switches are firm. It is odd having the speedo in the center, but the multi-function computer took care of that by putting a digital display of the speed at the bottom of the tach. I tend to watch the tach more and pace my speed by RPM's/gear selection (for example 4000 RPM's in 5th gear on my 1.8 yields about 92 MPH).
The shifting is easy and smooth. The clutch on the Mini is pretty light. I hear that the "S" model is heavier feeling (which I prefer). There's plenty of get up and go, if you keep the rev's high enough, but it's definitely not a screamer.
I must try the "S" for comparison. It's not that much more to step up.
The next move is to see what kind of impact both models will have on my insurance.
In short, I'm really impressed with the car. I just need to work the finances some and do some more research on it (as I found that the standard Mini 5 speed has unspcified problems around 25-30k miles).
I never thought that I'd seriously be considering a Mini. Hmmmm...