Wax or Sealant on wheels?

dawgboy

New member
Been searching around the site for information or advice on wheel protection. Whats the difference between a wax and a sealent? The current waxes I have are BlackFire Wet Diamond and Meguiars Deep Crystal Carnauba Wax. Would these be safte to apply to my wheels which are clear coated?
 
PrinceHoliday said:
Been searching around the site for information or advice on wheel protection. Whats the difference between a wax and a sealent? The current waxes I have are BlackFire Wet Diamond and Meguiars Deep Crystal Carnauba Wax. Would these be safte to apply to my wheels which are clear coated?
BFWD is not a wax, but a sealant. Black Fire makes a Metal Sealant targeted for wheels.
 
Collinite 845 is terrific on wheels. I had it on my wheels last winter (which was a doozy with lots of snow/salt/sand). When I finally got to clean my wheels in March, the stuff came right off with car soap.
 
I've never had any huge issues from using waxes on wheels. Yeah, I know...heat, ferrous contamination, brake pad dust...it all sounds like a recipe for disaster with a wax as opposed to a sealant huh? Thing is, I never experienced any of those terrible issues :nixweiss



No, I wouldn't use Souveran before a track day, but I don't think the waxes are as unsuitable for this as one might expect. Yeah, they do contaminate a little quicker than sealants, but then some people can make a good argument for not LSPing wheels period, finding that they're happier just leaving them "bare" (or using a good leaves-stuff-behind QD or spray LSP every time) and cleaning them with wheel cleaners.



Actually, I'm leaving the BBS wheels on my beater-Audi bare and just using FK425 or FK146 after I wash them (with Griot's Wheel Cleaner). To my eyes, they look *almost* as nice as the wheels I have all nicely LSPed and when the LSPed ones start to get near that "oughta redo 'em" point the bare wheels actually look *better*. IME the appearance advantage to LSPing wheels does start to drop off somewhat quickly.
 
If you (hand) wash regulary...every 1-2 weeks FK1000x2. If you get heavy contamination or extended wash intervals...wheel cleaner and FK425.
 
If the wheels are clear coated treat them like your paint. I use IW and it works very well. I have found "wheel waxes/sealants" to be a joke. They don't do anything a good wax or sealant already does. It just one more product to sell you and there are plenty willing to buy it for their "collections". So if your not into collecting and just want a product that does the job any good wax or sealant will do. The main thing is to use something.
 
Accumulator said:
but then some people can make a good argument for not LSPing wheels period, finding that they're happier just leaving them "bare" (or using a good leaves-stuff-behind QD or spray LSP every time) and cleaning them with wheel cleaners.



I dont seal the wheels on my personal car. It gets washed once a week and usually a good pressure washing is all thats needed. Otherwise soap and water gets the job done.
 
Anthony A said:
If the wheels are clear coated treat them like your paint...



I've been kinda surprised to find out how many of my wheels were powdercoated instead of (conventionally) painted. Didn't realize it in some cases until my painter started trying to strip the finish off to redo them...I woulda sworn they were just b/c paint (if pretty tough stuff).



I use IW and it works very well.



I've tried that a few times on my winter wheels, which IMO makes for a good, if demanding test. I wasn't impressed until I tried layering it, and then I changed my tune as several applications (spread a day or so apart) really did work better for me.



I have found "wheel waxes/sealants" to be a joke. They don't do anything a good wax or sealant already does...



That's what I always figured too, not that I've ever actually *tried* any of those "wheel products". Just seems silly to me (heh heh, I've been wrong before, but I don't think I am on this one).



The main thing is to use something.



Or at least keep 'em clean enough that you don't get pitting or other issues. I was kinda :nervous: about leaving the Audi's BBSs bare, but after two years they're just fine. Sure wouldn't want to neglect them the way I can my sealed wheels though!
 
Everyone slams Poorboys wheel sealant based on one attribute, it does not seem to bead well for long. I really like it because its a fantastic cleaner and is very easy to apply. I haven't found any wax/sealant that prevents road tar from sticking to my wheels, but the PBWS does a fantastic job of removing the tar and looks great.
 
yakky- I wonder if people would be more charitable towards the Poorboy's Wheel Sealant if it were called something else :think:
 
Accumulator said:
yakky- I wonder if people would be more charitable towards the Poorboy's Wheel Sealant if it were called something else :think:



I think they might, something along the lines of wheel care or cleaner-wax might work better.
 
yakky said:
I think they might, something along the lines of wheel care or cleaner-wax might work better.



Yeah, but then some people knee-jerk towards hatred when they read "cleaner-wax" too :rolleyes:
 
yakky said:
Everyone slams Poorboys wheel sealant based on one attribute, it does not seem to bead well for long. I really like it because its a fantastic cleaner and is very easy to apply. I haven't found any wax/sealant that prevents road tar from sticking to my wheels, but the PBWS does a fantastic job of removing the tar and looks great.



Sounds like a cleaner wax/sealant. There are eleventy thousand of those around. I'm sure it works well but so do many others. The obvious question to ask is if it's so great compared to other products you tried why not use it on the whole car? Why just wheels?
 
hercar said:
If you (hand) wash regulary...every 1-2 weeks FK1000x2. If you get heavy contamination or extended wash intervals...wheel cleaner and FK425.



You have got to be joking:If you get heavy contamination or extended wash intervals...wheel cleaner and FK425.[/QUOTE] What is FK425 going to do other than shine them up a little. It's only a QD and will wash off after the first rain.
 
Anthony A said:
Sounds like a cleaner wax/sealant. There are eleventy thousand of those around. I'm sure it works well but so do many others. The obvious question to ask is if it's so great compared to other products you tried why not use it on the whole car? Why just wheels?



I did ask that same question. The stuff looks fantastic on silver, I ended up doing a front fender on my suv. It looks like someone was able to get 2-3 layers of qd to stick on top of it somehow. Really deep and wet, but like mentioned doesn't last. As far as other cleaner waxes, other than AIO, nothing really cleans as well as this stuff. It is much easier to use than AIO. I need to test AIO vs the Wheel sealant and find out which lasts longer.
 
Yakky & Anthony A.- I see where both of you are coming from, but I do find that sometimes a certain product is *just right* for some given situation. Not *dramatically* better, but enough so that I'd rather reach for it than anything else. And, OTOH, if such subtleties aren't significant to somebody, well, that's cool too.



Easier to use than KAIO huh? That's something...



Legacy99 said:
You have got to be joking:If you get heavy contamination or extended wash intervals...wheel cleaner and FK425.
What is FK425 going to do other than shine them up a little. It's only a QD and will wash off after the first rain.[/QUOTE]



Heh heh, after the first rain my wheels usually look pretty nasty anyhow :D



Maybe I'm misreading something here...but that approach really works great for me on the V8's BBS wheels, and I was expecting to be disappointed. The FK425 adds just enough that they *are* shined up a little, and that little bit does matter (well, at least to me :D ). Plus, they seem to stay decent-looking a little longer and then clean up a little bit better. But eh, it's nothing all *that* dramatic I guess.



But I oughta try one of those brake dust repellant products, bet that'd be better (if more expensive). That might help with how the brakdust looks so terrible after a rain.
 
Back
Top