I called both hotels and the Staten Island Hotel is cheaper and they charge $154 + tax for a single room and I am waiting to hear back from them about group rates.
EDIT: After doing a little searching on the web you can book individual rooms, single person, for $124/night + tax with AAA.
EDIT: After doing a little searching on the web you can book individual rooms, single person, for $124/night + tax with AAA.