Stay Away from Clay Magic!!

S

SHPatel

New member
Yesterday my friend bought a brand new 2003 Black Nissan Maxima. We did'nt even allow the dealer to take any of the plastic off.



This morning we decided to clay both of our cars. Well when we went to Pep Boys I opted for the Mother's Clay Bar like I always do and he opted for the cheaper Clay Magic Bar.



So we're off and we start claying away on our freshly washed cars. After about a 15 minutes into the job he starts freaking out. The clay magic is leaaving some sort of white residue all over the paint. When we tried to remove it with my clay bar it would not come out. We even tried glaze but still no difference.



So at this point he's fuming and we go back to Pep Boys and pick up Mother's Clay. Needless to say the area where we used the Mother's was absolutely flawless. We're still trying to figure out how to get the white stains out of his paint.



So from our experience it's best to avoid this clay and stick with high quality clay like Mother's.
 
That's funny. I've always had good experiences with Clay Magic.



I wonder what could have happened...?
 
Thats a pretty bold statement to make about Clay Magic clay bars based on one experience. Did you use the lube that came with the kit? Did you let it dry on the paint? Did you try washing the car again?
 
I definitely wouldn't judge Clay Magic by the experience you had with one bar. Besides, it was your friend using the Clay Magic so you really can't know if he did something wrong. I've used Clay Magic on dozens of cars for the last couple years and I've never had anything but a postitive experience. Saying that Clay Magic is bad based on one experience that may have been caused by something other than the clay is a little hasty. I've never seen any substance left by any clay bar I've ever used. That doesn't really sound like something that the clay would have put down. What were you doing claying a 2003 automobile anyway? I wouldn't think a car that new would need anything more than a waxing.
 
I think you guys are probably right...I am kind of jumping to conclusions and it was my friend doing the claying and not me.



As far as claying a 2003 Maxima, it was to get all the glue and other crud that had adehered to the car in the last 4 months that it sat on the lot for. The paint was rough in areas that did not have plastic on it and there was glue all over the place.



Sorry to jump to conclusions. Thanks for knocking some sense into me guys :D
 
Here's a thought... Maybe he was just smearing this adhesive around that you were trying to remove. That's a thought. Just out of curiosity, why did you go back for more mother's? Why not just use the bar you were using?



Definitely give Clay Magic another shot. It is really awesome stuff as far as the consumer clay bars go. Mother's would be second on my list for sure. I like Clay Magic a bit better because it is a little stickier and I don't feel like I'm going to drop it. It kind of sticks to your fingers and helps keep you from dropping it.
 
Jngrbrdman said:
Here's a thought... Maybe he was just smearing this adhesive around that you were trying to remove. That's a thought. Just out of curiosity, why did you go back for more mother's? Why not just use the bar you were using?



Definitely give Clay Magic another shot. It is really awesome stuff as far as the consumer clay bars go. Mother's would be second on my list for sure. I like Clay Magic a bit better because it is a little stickier and I don't feel like I'm going to drop it. It kind of sticks to your fingers and helps keep you from dropping it.
Click to expand...



I made him get another one because I really don't like anyone using my stuff in case he drops it or something. Plus the only people that I let use my equipment are people who can detail at the same caliber I do.

Basically I was teaching my friend how to detail today and so he had no prior experience with alot of the items we used. It was kind of frustrating at times but atleast now he knows how to properly detail his car:xyxthumbs
 
Wow, a car sat on a dealer lot for 4 months and they never removed the plastic? That's usually the first thing they do when it comes in. The only way to avoid that is usually if you order the car and leave very specific instructions.



Also, I don't think clay is the product to use to remove glue. Did you wash the car after removing the plastic and prior to claying?
 
I'm puzzled too. I've always had very good experience with Clay Magic. I'd have to agree with others about the glue residue left on the paint.
 
I've used the Clay Magic three times now and have nothing but good things to say about it. I also agree with others that the adhesive was spread around when claying.
 
I think it was just one of those "freaky" things. Once I got some Pinnacle poly clay, and both bars were like little yellow cement chunks. Dry & coarse, unable to fold. :angry My usual bars are Mother's & Clay Magic. I understand your frustration though.....needless to say that was my last time with poly clay.



PEACE
 
Clay majic is owned by Auto Majic. They own the patent for clay in the USA. They have won ever court case against every competitor for the use of the clay bar. Very soon you will findall clay in some way will have to be purchased through Auto majic. Their clay is one of the best out there.
 
I have had excelent results with Clay Magic. I am glad to hear you like the Mothers as I have bought like 6 bars in last month. The kits were on sale for $3.00 and I could not pass up just one more after the orignal few I bought! I have not tried it but figured it has to be better than Meguires as theres is not very good in my opinion. (from my experience) Now if I could get clay magic so cheap! :)
 
I've heard different..that the importers are using a different way of making it and their patent doesn't cover it...
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top