I’m not a detailer, but I am a car nit and have dealt with a few detailers over the years (I have moved a few times)
To be honest in the 3 locations I have lived in, I found one detailer I liked.
I just recently tried 2 different detailers up here in southern NH. I was unhappy with both.
1) One the car was bad. I understand having minor problems, but this was bad. The car was a black grand prix, and whatever he used to polish the car left MAJOR swirl marks.
Not the typical look hard and you can find them.. Bad enough that my wife (not picky at all) asked.. What did he do to my car! I had picked up the car after hours so I called him back the next day and he said "no problem bring it back in and I will take a look"
So I met him the next day, and he said he didn't know what happened and said he would take care of it right away (I’m sure it was wasn't him that did the work since he was very apologetic about how it came out).
I pick it up again the next night after hours, and he fixed the paint.. Actually came out very nice...BUT the polish was splattered all over the windows and door jams, under the trunk etc. (I paid $179 for the complete job 2 days before!).
I didn’t call him back, I decided at this point to finish it myself.
I am not usually a complainer, and I gave him a second chance to make it right.
After talking to a couple people about his shop, they said he used to be the best in the area, but his business has taken off so well, he has hired others to do most of the work and the quality has fallen.
2) Most recently I had the detail shop at the dealer do my wife's 05 odyssey EXL with Nav & RES that has 6K miles in it. It was not bad at all, had a couple dried milk spots on the leather seats from my kids (4 months, and 19 months old) and lots of bugs on the grill, brake dust on wheels etc. So I bring it in for the $199 5 star reconditioning. (I just sold her other car, so I figured I would splurge when it went in for a oil change and surprise her with a "new" car again.)
Well I picked it up, and they did a great job on the body and wheels, the interior came out good to.. But the problems were
1) The windows were all heavily streaked, and missed spots, so bad on the windshield I stopped at AutoZone on the way home to pickup some Stoners to clean the windshield.
2) They never cleaned the dead bugs off the grill, just washed over them.
3) They stuck another dealer sticker on the back tailgate!! (I removed the first one with a heat gun the day I brought the van home) and they stuck another one on!! ARG!
4) They never cleaned the rear DVD screen (finger prints all over it) This one is minor and easy to forget to do, just mentioned it for completeness.
Anyway, I am long winded here. Personally I would pay more for a better job, but sometimes you do not get what you paid for. I feel the 5 star $199 cleaning on the van should have been easy for a detailer, not much elbow grease needed, it just needed the "detail" and they still blew it.
Its amazing, the one detailer I really liked was also one of the cheaper ones in the area where his shop was!!
I have also bought and sold many cars over the years, and I am a true believer the MOST important part of a detail to get right is the windows!! Make sure not to leave any streaks inside or out on the windows!!
Thanks for listening to me, if anyone can recommend a good detailer in southern NH, or northern mass I would appreciate it.. I do not have time (between work and my 2 young children) to break out my PC and hit my Silverado...
-Bill
Dover, NH