I tried the EO wax-as-u-dry. I used it throughout this past winter as a QD as a matter of trying it out, Walmart had it for $3.98. It seemed to me you have to put it on very sparingly or else it could be difficult to buff out. As the bottle states, "shake for more wax", there was a difference in the wax it put down between just picking it up and applying and shaking it up good first. I liked the shine it rendered as a QD but if you put it on too heavy it could lead to some heavier than desired rubbing. I liked it overall for what I used it as but I would not count on it the way I would a carnuba paste. It reminded me of Clear Pearl with a higher wax content or at least of thicker consistency than the CP. Try it you might like it.