New P16S Carnauba!

I was thinking the same thing. Is the bulk #1 Yellow Carnauba the same as the pure Carnauba touted by the leading waxes? Can someone knowledgeable confirm this?



If so, I've found pure flakes for sale as cheaply as $8 a pound. Adding some to S100 would surely produce a more durable wax, though it would compromise its ease of use a bit.
 
I suspect that waxes are more than just the sum of their ingredients. Not unlike food. You and I can cook up the same ingredients, but mine might taste like crap and yours might be awesome. So wax plus more carnauba is unlikely to yield the secret formula to Zymol Vintage or something. Really, all that matters though is that you like what you end up with. :)



It would be interesting to see some longer term results, and also some comparos of the hybrid product to the two originals. It's a neat idea though.



I would suggest you use a double boiler too, but maybe boil water in a pot, and melt the wax in a small plastic cup. That way you can keep it in the cup, not ruin a pan, not worry about contamination from previous melted products or the soup you made last week, etc. Plus you could make smaller batches. It would seem kind of a shame to melt a whole brick of $70 Souveran and end up with something that sucked. Plus you could control the ratio more instead of just whatever size the thing came in.



You all got me thinking a little about melting some Blitz and #16 together. They both sound to be durable (haven't tried the Blitz) but I've heard Blitz can be a bit dust-attracting.



I do think it's funny that someone suggesting mixing liquids is a bad idea, but somehow melting solids together is ok. It seems to me both are of the same idea, I mean both are made of numerous different chemicals and carriers and such. Anyway, cool idea. It's even cooler that it mixed together well. I'd be worried there might be some separation while it cooled or something. :)
 
I am willing to trade someone near me something for a sample of some kind of durable insulator wax (Collinite). I think the durability from this mixed with something like Natty's or S100 would make an excellent topper.



If noone in the VA area has Collnite, where/for how much can I buy it?
 
I suspect that waxes are more than just the sum of their ingredients. Not unlike food. You and I can cook up the same ingredients, but mine might taste like crap and yours might be awesome. So wax plus more carnauba is unlikely to yield the secret formula to Zymol Vintage or something.
Click to expand...



I agree with this. Nonetheless, it should be true that taking an already useable, soft wax like S100 and blending it with pure carnauba would almost certainly produce a good and harder wax. It wouldn't be Zymol Vintage. On the other hand, those guys tout waxes which are 60% Carnauba, and on previous threads no one could find commercially available "white" Carnauba that was different than the best light yellow #1 Carnauba. So maybe Zymol has access to some secret hoard of Carnauba that no one else in the universe can buy or even find, but otherwise I'll just assume it's very good pure Carnauba which usually costs less than $10-$20 a pound in bulk form. (Unless of course someone has objective evidence or a link suggesting otherwise.)



Regardless, I don't want to get anyone off track.



I just thought -- given the easy mixing of #16 and s100. Surely adding pure Carnauba to S100 would work -- though it might not be an improvement -- since woodworkers blend their own polishing waxes all the time.
 
Most excellent thread! You goota love this stuff.:up



Now the pots used for the experiment are permanently sealed. They are ready for their own infomercial.:lol



I recently mixed up a one step that I am testing now. The ingredients are as follows:



50% Collinite #845 IW

25% 4* UPC

25 % HT Light Cut



Call it a winter one step or whatever. It removes, cleans, and protects. It seems to be performing very well so far after a month since application on a daily beater.
 
jvcn said:
I agree with this. Nonetheless, it should be true that taking an already useable, soft wax like S100 and blending it with pure carnauba would almost certainly produce a good and harder wax. It wouldn't be Zymol Vintage. On the other hand, those guys tout waxes which are 60% Carnauba, and on previous threads no one could find commercially available "white" Carnauba that was different than the best light yellow #1 Carnauba. So maybe Zymol has access to some secret hoard of Carnauba that no one else in the universe can buy or even find, but otherwise I'll just assume it's very good pure Carnauba which usually costs less than $10-$20 a pound in bulk form. (Unless of course someone has objective evidence or a link suggesting otherwise.)



Regardless, I don't want to get anyone off track.



I just thought -- given the easy mixing of #16 and s100. Surely adding pure Carnauba to S100 would work -- though it might not be an improvement -- since woodworkers blend their own polishing waxes all the time.
Click to expand...

Blending in more carnauba may or may not add durability. It might dilute whatever polymers are added in to modify the durability of the base wax. Who knows. Zymol's waxes don't tend to be known for their durability, though I've never used any of them. Anyway, it's not like I know what will happen. I'm just saying it may not be better. Only one way to find out, though... ;)
 
One more caveat. The more "natural" wax-heavy pastes should be safer to blend. Many of the petroleum heavy liquids might be miscible but shouldn't be heated.



Heat + Petroleum smelling products = ??? Fewer Autopians?



:nixweiss
 
What a cool thread. I never thought of mixing solids before, although I have mixed liquids. PLease keep us posted on all of your results.



I think the plastic cup in the boiling water is a great idea, you can make smaller batches in case things go awry. PLus using small chucks you could measure them on a kitchen scale to ensure repeatability.
 
That's it!!! I gave in to temptation.



I was totally bored and assigned to helping with the laundry.



It's snowing outside and I'm trying to avoid doing serious work/work. So while waiting for the clothes to dry I took an ounce of leftover old Gold Class I was prepared to throw away, mixed with a couple ounces of Eagle Nanowax, some UPP, some #9 and a bit of WAUD. Why? No reason. I wasn't impressed by either GC or Nano and was prepared to throw them away, but then...

Anyway I used the mixture (latte with extra milk looking) to polish our white washing machine. I will say that it was a lot easier to apply and buff off than GC or Nano by itself.



Durability? You've gotta be kidding.



Nothing to compare it with. But I think the wife is going to be surprised when she heads to the basement.





File this under the Idle Hands column...:lol
 
I just waxed my car with some Snatty's #1600. To say the paint looks wet would be a serious understatement.



I prepped by polishing (polishing pads for both) with Vanilla Moose then AIO and finished it off with a blend of #16, S100 and Nattys. I'd say the ratio was 40% S100, 40% #16 and 20% Natty's.



I took a couple pics, they may or may not end up too dark (it was about 30 minutes before sundown and I was in the shade) so I'll take a couple more tomorrow.



Thanks for the idea, Chris! :wavey
 
RCBuddha said:
:eek: I only have S100/Natty's! Better re-melt and add some #16!!!!!



2005: The year of the "Franken-Nubas"......



Eshine has P16S, Scott has Snatty's #1600, and I have N100......Whose up for some Meguiar's #42 (26 and 16 together)?
Click to expand...



Did you try your N100 yet? How did it work out? I should have brokeke up the #16 and P21S and only used half of each! LOL. I want to do more mixing. I have always had a hard time deciding between #16 and P21S, I feel so at peace knowing I can use P16S now! LOL
 
eShine said:
Did you try your N100 yet? How did it work out? I should have brokeke up the #16 and P21S and only used half of each! LOL. I want to do more mixing. I have always had a hard time deciding between #16 and P21S, I feel so at peace knowing I can use P16S now! LOL
Click to expand...



Chris,

I've been itching to try my hybrid....but alas...its raining and it won't stop till next tuesday/wednesday....:( Rest assured, I will be waxing on tuesday or wednesday morning!
 
I was really torn between using the Shokar stuff on my car or my hybrid. The hybrid won out because I just am not that fond of sealant on my own black car. If I had a silver car, I would probably have gone with Shokar.
 
Wow, this is really cool. I have never thought of this before....and I'm surprised that the results you guys are getting are better than the waxes alone!!!!



Keep the ideas coming....somebody wanna try a Souveran combo? (Colinate and Souveran?)
 
pigeonbus said:
Wow, this is really cool. I have never thought of this before....and I'm surprised that the results you guys are getting are better than the waxes alone!!!!



Keep the ideas coming....somebody wanna try a Souveran combo? (Colinate and Souveran?)
Click to expand...



I was also curious as to how the mixed products would work. I was wondering if they would clash and perform terrible. I was surprised how dam well they worked together! I guess its like two tops companies getting together and spilling the beans on their secret ingredients thus creating a super product. I still can't get over how nice the P16S works! Every time I used the P21S I wish it had a bit of #16's qualities, and vice versa with the #16. I just feel like Going over the Cobra with the P16S, Dawn washing it, Applying more P16S, Dawn washing it... To me, its the perfect product!
 
One thing I don't get is why would it be wetter looking than the wettest of the individual waxes? It's not like doing this puts down 2 or 3 layers of wax at once. You'll still have the same film build. In fact applying one, waiting, applying the next, waiting, etc would probably result in more film build and more "carnauba" look.



I'm not saying you guys aren't seeing it, just saying it sounds pretty weird. I can see maybe mixing a beauty wax with a durability wax to get sort of a blend of the two. I dunno... I'm not too keen on melting down Souveran, but maybe I'll try a little bit... :nixweiss
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top