etml12- Thanks for posting that, now I have a better idea what the potential problem is. Not having retained whatever such knowledge I gleaned from my chem courses, it never woulda occurred to me. So there *is* more to it than just making that final rinse more acidic.
If we accept that vinegar is a cationic softener (as when it says "works on *some* [emphasis mine] materials in a similar way" we're assuming that includes MF), this might be a "degree of significance" issue, where one effect has to be balanced against another. I think of caveats against using "regular" fabric softeners on cotton and this brings up a topic that has aroused a bit of contention here in the past.
The idea is that softeners will leave a residue that a) can cause smearing and/or b) can negatively impact absorbency. I found that some softeners do both, and in a *huge* way (e.g., Final Touch) and that others (e.g., Ultra Downy) *used in very small quanties* do not do either, at least not to an extent that I can discern.
After all the previous discussion here, I basically quit using softeners other than vinegar on household towels/washcloths. Some were just fine, nice and soft. Others were stiff and coarse-feeling, sometimes to the point where my wife wouldn't use them. All were absorbent. When, at my wife's insistance, I went back to doing *her* towels/etc. with the Utra Downy, they were nice and soft and there were no absorbency/smearing (when used to clean eyeglass lenses) issues.
Getting back to MFs...the two I washed without vinegar are now more absorbent, but are also marring CDs, which they did *not* do before. If some softener (e.g., vinegar) adds surface lubricity to the point of preventing that marring, would it be worth some loss of adsorbency?
And do cationic softeners have the same effect on MF adsorbency that they presumably have on natural fiber absorbency?
I still can't offer an explanation for why I have the experiences that I do when laundering textiles :nixweiss I have some CBTs that have gone from nice and soft to coarse and stiff, no way would I ever touch paint with 'em (my plush MFs don't do this for some reason). I blame my crappy water and buy new toweling frequently but I sure wish I could get to the bottom of it and have a real solution.