HD speed question

[dogma]

Will HD speed and Poxy look as good as Nitroseal ? Not worried about durability.

 

[Thomas Dekany]

Very interesting question - I haven't compared, but maybe today I can test it for you.

 

[David Fermani]

Assuming that you didn't polish 1st, I would say HD Speed/Poxy would look better. I'd say anytime you can create better gloss and clarity 1st, you're creating a better finish.

 

[brownbob06]

Isn't polishing a necessary step before nitro seal though?



I used undo then speed when I Nitro Sealed and it turned out great.

 

[Thomas Dekany]

That is true, true for all LSPs.

Isn't polishing a necessary step before nitro seal though?



I used undo then speed when I Nitro Sealed and it turned out great.

 

[dogma]

I guess I should have clarified my question. What I wanted to ask was . Does speed then Poxy look as good as Uno then Nitroseal.



I think Nitroseal is extremely shinny and wet. probably one of the best out there.



My Nitro seal was opened about 6 weeks ago, I am going to use it again and see what happens.

 

[Woody Wax]

I guess I should have clarified my question. What I wanted to ask was . Does speed then Poxy look as good as Uno then Nitroseal.



I think Nitroseal is extremely shinny and wet. probably one of the best out there.



My Nitro seal was opened about 6 weeks ago, I am going to use it again and see what happens.

IMO, No

Speed topped with Poxy looks fantastic, however Nitro Seal is just in a class of it’s own.



Cheers Daniel

 

[Thomas Dekany]

I agree with Daniel. Now SPEED topped with NS is what I can't wait to see.

 

[imported_reeeko991]

Speed/POXY is the wettest finish I've been able to get. Amazing !!

 

[David Fermani]

This whole subject is begging for a comparison!!!:showpics

I guess I should have clarified my question. What I wanted to ask was . Does speed then Poxy look as good as Uno then Nitroseal.

I would say NO, only because if you're finishing with the latest UNO(which is a cutting polish),you're leaving some gloss on the table by not using a finishing polish prior to sealing.



If both finishes are "finished out" the same way (corrected with UNO and then final polished with SPEED),I'd give the edge to the one that had Nitro Seal on it. The product looks great! And POXY ain't no slouch either... :nono:

My Nitro seal was opened about 6 weeks ago, I am going to use it again and see what happens.

NS can last for a long time after it's opened, but providing that you super tightened the cap and stored it in a cool place (refriderator). As long as the consistency is still the same....you're good to go.