Compare P21S Total Wash to Simple Green

E

explorer

New member
I use P21S but it seems like a lot of you use Simple Green and I was wondering how it compares to P21S .



Is it a better , worse or equal cleaner?



How about safety , is it as safe as P21S?



Thanks in advance.:wavey
 
From my personal experience, I've noticed that even diluted Simple Green "etched" unfinished aluminum and stainless steel. In my naive days, I even used Simple Green as a wheel cleaner. Big mistake. After about 2 years it destroyed the clear coat on my Nissan 300ZX wheels.



I am a very big fan of P21S Total Body Wash. I use it everywhere, including wheel wells, engine compartment, rubber floor mats, etc. Great product with a very high safety profile.



Dean
 
Yep, what Dean said :xyxthumbs P21S TAW is SAFE, and Simple Green is NOT. It's IS all a matter of degree, but that's what it boils down to.



I have usee them both, but the Simple Green is something *I* generally keep away from my cars. The TAW might not clean quite as well, but it's VERY close and it WILL NOT hurt anything.



The kind of damage Simple Green does (no, it doesn't ALWAYS do any damage and many have NO problems with it at all) is generally irreparable. Just not worth the risk, IMO.
 
Is there a cheaper (more readily available...shipping is a @#$%&) alternative? My P21S TAW is running low :sosad



VV



Accumulator said:
Yep, what Dean said :xyxthumbs P21S TAW is SAFE, and Simple Green is NOT. It's IS all a matter of degree, but that's what it boils down to.



I have usee them both, but the Simple Green is something *I* generally keep away from my cars. The TAW might not clean quite as well, but it's VERY close and it WILL NOT hurt anything.



The kind of damage Simple Green does (no, it doesn't ALWAYS do any damage and many have NO problems with it at all) is generally irreparable. Just not worth the risk, IMO.
Click to expand...
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top