303 hi tech fabric guard test results

a dreary, rainy sunday will make you do strange things. i came up with a quick product test to entertain myself...





product: 303 Aerospace Hi Tech Fabric Guard





i just purchased a cheap pack of general use microfiber towels from Sam's (25 pack for $11.50). i'm actually fairly impressed with them after their first wash...equal or softer than the Target Vroom brand i typically use.



anyway, below are pics of the setup. pretty self explanatory. i chose three offenders: chocolate sauce, spaghetti sauce, and dark soda.



the towel on the left is untreated, never used, and freshly washed. the towel on the right was treated with the 303 product and allowed to dry for 30 minutes (even though the directions say 4-24 hours).



i used a spoon to smear the offenders into the towels. you'll find the results interesting.







pics...









the victims:



stain_before1.jpg






the offenders:



stain_before_offenders.jpg






the defense:





stain_before_303.jpg




test started:





stain_lineup.jpg






soda on untreated towel:





stain_before_no303_soda.jpg






soda on towel with 303:





stain_before_303_soda.jpg






untreated chocolate syrup:





stain_before_no303_choc.jpg






treated chocolate syrup:





stain_before_303_choc.jpg






the soda would not soak into the towel on its own, so i helped it along by smearing it a bit. i left a few drops sit there to see if they would eventually soak in, but they did not.



total time offenders were allowed to dry: 3 hours





untreated w/ dried soda:



stain_during_no303_soda.jpg




treated w/ dried soda...not really dry though and still beading in areas that i did not rub in:



stain_during_303_soda.jpg




untreated w/ chocolate:



stain_during_no303_choc.jpg




treated w/ chocolate:



stain_during_303_choc.jpg




untreated after rinsing w/ warm water:



stain_rinsed_no303.jpg




treated after rinsing w/ warm water:



stain_rinsed_303.jpg




stain removers applied to both towels (only spaghetti sauce stains remained on both towels). folex on top, oxy clean spray on bottom:



stain_303_folex_oxy.jpg






light agitation on stained areas and both rinsed with warm water again.



untreated is stain free!



stain_after_no303.jpg




treated still has spaghetti stain slightly visible. hmmmmmm.



stain_after_303_b.jpg


stain_after_303_a.jpg






so...i did not mix up the towels or switch them. any ideas why the TREATED towel would stain and the untreated did not? obviously not what i was expecting!
 
that's quite an interesting test.



Here's my guess:



I think the reason why the treated side didn't come out as clean was because the fabric treatment hadn't completely dried. I believe on some instructions they will tell you to wait 1 hr in between coat and it has to dry for 12-24 hours.



It'll also state to get the fabric clean first before you apply, and I have a feeling that if you apply it to something dirty, you'll only set the stain even further and make it harder to remove.



Maybe to test this, you should treat one towel and let it dry completely for a day. And then try it again. I'd be interested to see the results.
 
BlackElantraGT said:
that's quite an interesting test.



Here's my guess:



I think the reason why the treated side didn't come out as clean was because the fabric treatment hadn't completely dried. I believe on some instructions they will tell you to wait 1 hr in between coat and it has to dry for 12-24 hours.



It'll also state to get the fabric clean first before you apply, and I have a feeling that if you apply it to something dirty, you'll only set the stain even further and make it harder to remove.



agreed...i did not let it sit for 4-24 hours as the instructions stated. it definitely worked as far as beading moisture, etc...but perhaps without curing, the product makes it MORE vulnerable to stains until then?



regarding your second idea, both towels were brand new out of the bag and straight into the washing machine. product was applied to as clean a surface as it could be.



also interesting that the microfiber resisted staining as much as it did to begin with. i don't have carpet pieces to test on, or i'd redo this with other fabrics.
 
Nice thread!



I bought the fabric guard with a complete 303 packege,

It is better to use somthing in my interior carbet and trunk

so I cleaned them pretty well with vaccum and treated them with 303 fabricguard

I also treated the fabric under hood that helps reduce the heat of the engine.



Any better products out there?



again a great thread and thanks for taking the time to do this!
 
paradigm said:
regarding your second idea, both towels were brand new out of the bag and straight into the washing machine. product was applied to as clean a surface as it could be.



also interesting that the microfiber resisted staining as much as it did to begin with. i don't have carpet pieces to test on, or i'd redo this with other fabrics.



what I mean about it being clean to begin with is that while the product was in its drying process, there was already a mess to begin with and so as it was drying (3-4 hrs your experiment was going on), it was setting your stain even further.



also, i don't think the microfiber resisted staining any more than another type of fabric. Only a few hours had passed and I'm assuming this was done indoors, so heat wasn't helping it set any faster, like what would happen in your car if you were to leave it baking in the sun. That's why I don't buy into a lot of infomercial products because their "artificial" stains are newer and easier to clean off.
 
makes sense...i actually thought about putting them in the dryer to "help" it along. haha. i'll probably retry after letting a towel cure for a full day...then let the stains set for a full day as well.
 
I'm not sure if you mean putting it in the dryer to help the fabric guard dry or to set your stains even further, but your wife would kill you if she dried her clothes and she has chocolate syrup and spaghetti sauce on her clean clothes!
 
Cleaning Fool said:
Next test is to see how long it lasts



Only problem with this is a towel test compared to fabric on your seats...the elements and variables they see are a lot different.
 
my thought is that perhaps as the 303 was still curing the added staining items were basically mixing with the 303 and becoming part of it? maybe that is why they say all that time to dry/cure? the directions say to get it evenly wet which I would think means to make it soaked?
 
Yeah, to do a test like this you REALLY need to follow the manufacturer's directions to a tee. Try it again and allow the Fabric Guard to dry for 24 hours.
 
Back
Top