Ah, OK..still good numbers no matter what.
One set per exercise vs. many: I`ve been doing well using only one set per exercise. I might do two/three but if I do I change something significantly enough that it`s not just doing the same thing. I got the idea from Clarence Bass and the meta-study by Ralph Carpinelli (with which I have some issues, but I don`t dismiss it out of hand), and found out (to my surprise) that it works well for me when circumstances forced me to drastically limit the frequency and duration of my workouts. I do it because *it works for me*, simple as that.
Bass recently cited a new study that showed that for men (but not women), strength/endurance gains were the same with one/more, but that hypertrophy was better with more than with one. I found that interesting even though I don`t plan to do more than one, at least not very often (again, based on irrefutable, first-hand experience). BUT..oh man, did Bass`s take on that study disappoint me!
He seemed to take the study`s results as some kind of personal criticism or somesuch. He was weirdly defensive and disparaging; apparently any results that differ from his experiences and opinions are unwelcome and worthy of ridicule. He even leveled criticism at people wanting to "bulk up", saying that he wanted "functional muscle" instead, and he even poked fun at people who might want to compete in bodybuilding contests. This from a guy who was a long-time competitive bodybuilder. Sigh...I expect better from him. In fairness, I`ll point out that it seemed out of character for him, maybe he was having a bad day and needed to step away from the keyboard.
Dick Winett chimed in with similar criticism just loaded with rhetorical fallacies.
Neither of them criticized *the study*, but rather its *results*. Both went on to criticize guys who do more than one set...their motivations, their training, and their presumed results.
Why so defensive?!? Why so critical of others about whom you know nothing?
Hey, the study showed what it showed, and more info is good whether you choose to act on it or not.