RaysWay
Autopia Specialist
Yep Pinnacle Advanced Compound does have more cut than BF SRC Compound.
Maybe an older formula of SRC was more aggressive? Or are you thinking of Advanced Swirl Remover since the Compound is fairly new?
UPDATED 9/2015: Autopia Polish Comparison Chart
- Thread starter RaysWay
- Start date
Yep Pinnacle Advanced Compound does have more cut than BF SRC Compound.
Maybe an older formula of SRC was more aggressive? Or are you thinking of Advanced Swirl Remover since the Compound is fairly new?
Nick Rutter told me the newest SRC Compound has a bit more cut than Advanced compund(not swirl remover), while Advanced compound may finish a bit better. Not saying who's right or wrong, just what I heard.
RaysWay
Autopia Specialist
Whoa that'd be news to me if the new formula is that much stronger. I think the chart was made with the old version of BF SRC but I'll find out today and update the chart as needed.
Please do, as I'm going to pull the trigger on one of these, depending on your answer. Thanks.
jrock645
New member
Curious why you're so interested in those two? They're not often discussed around here, and certainly aren't mentioned as gold standard polishes.
I like trying different things.
jrock645
New member
Gotcha.
RaysWay
Autopia Specialist
That's strange, I would consider both of those as gold standard polishes. I would gladly put them head to head v.s. any other compound. I've removed 1000 grit sanding marks with almost no need for a finishing polish with the Pinnacle Compound in front of a very skeptical person at MTE this year. But I guess everyone has their favorites.
I wouldn't judge a product or tool by how many people talk about them either. The Flex 3401 is rarely talked about these days for some reason but it's still one of the best DA polishers on the market.
I wouldn't judge a product or tool by how many people talk about them either. The Flex 3401 is rarely talked about these days for some reason but it's still one of the best DA polishers on the market.
jrock645
New member
Like with the 3401(lately anyway, was t the case a while back), I guess they're just not trending at the moment. Seems Meguiars and Menzerna are standard bearers, with 3D/HD being the new kid on the block.
RaysWay
Autopia Specialist
Ah ok. Ya that's true I guess they're not trending. But if you guys want to try samples add my name to the next order with a request for either BF or Pinnacle Compound sample and I'll add it to your order.
Rod73
Member
I am curious where the new McKee line fits in here?
rlmccarty2000
Active member
With Griots and Rupes pushing systems with their polishers many very good polishes may find their way to the back of the closet. I have used Blackfire polishes in the past but now find myself reaching for my Rupes polishes or Menzerma when using my microfiber pads.
Agreed.
jrock645
New member
Cant go wrong with Menzerna. The blackfire and wolfgang polishes are made by menzerna, so that bodes well. Ive had good experiences with the wg polishes.
RaysWay
Autopia Specialist
Confirmed you were correct Brewins. Nick told me the new formula of BLACKFIRE SRC Compound cuts more than the Pinnacle version and after using it all weekend at Detail Fest, I can say I like it even more than the Pinnacle version. It doesn't have a super strong chemical smell like Uber Compound which really messes with my sinuses. I'll have to give the new formula a full blown test once I get my garage all squared away this weekend. I'm excited to put this new formula up against some of my other favorites.
xxxxxin'!Confirmed you were correct Brewins. Nick told me the new formula of BLACKFIRE SRC Compound cuts more than the Pinnacle version and after using it all weekend at Detail Fest, I can say I like it even more than the Pinnacle version. It doesn't have a super strong chemical smell like Uber Compound which really messes with my sinuses. I'll have to give the new formula a full blown test once I get my garage all squared away this weekend. I'm excited to put this new formula up against some of my other favorites.
Thanks!
Angus
AspiringProductSpecialist
Strong chemical smells mess with my sinuses (and give me headaches) too. Knowing the new version of BF SRC didn't bother you is helpful to know. It would also be super helpful if you could add a chemical odor level to the chart. I love using FG400, but had to wear a mask using it over the weekend.
Looks like the sticker is coming off that XFE 7 - clearly a defective unit - how about I do you a favor and take it off your hands? Really it's no problem.
RaysWay
Autopia Specialist
That's a good idea. We'd have to come up with a standardized way to test smell so it would be done the same way for every polish.
Looks like the sticker is coming off that XFE 7 - clearly a defective unit - how about I do you a favor and take it off your hands? Really it's no problem.
It already found a new home
Mp0wer
New member
Ray where would carpro essence fall into the chart?