Wow, a 4 1/2 year old thread, that's gotta be just about a record...
Anyway, I'll chime in, 'cause i love me some wings. My favorite wings ever are at Fathead's Bar & Grill in Pittsburgh, PA. Honorable mention would go to Quaker Steak and Lube (the original location in Sharon, PA did seem a little better to me, but that's probably psychological).
I will say that since I moved away from the east coast, I've had a hard time even finding decent wings, much less good wings. Good wings really do seem to be centered around Buffalo (surprising, I know)... with western NY and wester PA having lots of good wings, and the farther away you go, the sketchier they get.
Of the one's on the list, I'd say Buffalo Wild Wings are the best, and Hooter's are miserable.