Quick Impressions & Comparison: Prima Amigo

davidmelis

New member
PRIMA AMIGO QUICK IMPRESSIONS

Prima 1.jpg

Help, I need a quick filler!

My daily driver got caught in a 3-day rain. The paint still looks good, but I knew that protection was almost gone when my wool wash mitt did not glide over the paint like it normally does. After inspection, I noticed some new scratches on the driver's side back quarter panel. (Arrrg! Black car owners were not meant to have kids I guess? Or the other way around, maybe.) Also, though I was very careful with drying, there were some water spots left on the “naked” paint. Because of these issues, I decided the car needed a Pre-Wax Cleaner before I slapped some Carnauba back on the paint.

A wonderful forum member just sent me a sample of Prima Amigo to try. So, here is a review of that product. Personally, I understand a product much better when I can compare it to things I am familiar with. *So for this review, I tested the product side-by-side with Pinnacle Paint Cleansing Lotion, Mother’s Pre-Wax Cleaner, and a standard all-in-one cleaner sealant (Mother’s Reflections).

Prima2.jpg
(Notice the scratches and the water spots left on the "naked" paint.)

ABOUT PRIMA

From the company's copy, "Prima Amigo is amazingly unique. It is a paintwork cleanser...It is a polymer-based glaze... It is even a super-fine polish which levels up to 3000 grit imperfections- when used with a Porter Cable (or similar) polisher. Combine all three properties and you can see why we think it doesn't fall into any currently defined categories of car care products. Mild cleaners in Amigo break up oxidation and remove "dead" paint. Embedded grime is gently lifted from the surface. Mineral deposits from water spots disappear. It is the perfect prep-step for well-cared-for paint that needs a cleansing before wax application. As a polymer-based glaze, it fills slight imperfections, adds stunning gloss while leaving the finish slick to the touch. What's unique about Amigo as a glaze is that it is polymer-based. Although it doesn't provide protection the way Prima Epic will, it does allow you to go directly to your wax step without any bonding or durability issues. Try that with a "normal" glaze and your protection will simply rinse off. Prima Amigo allows you to fill imperfections, add gloss then seal it in with your wax. No other product on the market gives you what Prima Amigo gives you. If you have ever fought with black paint as you tried to remove the very last bit of hazing left by your polish steps, you will truly appreciate Prima Amigo. Used with your PC polisher, it will remove the lightest of surface imperfections. Black becomes a crystal lagoon of depth and clarity. Red becomes a bright liquidy glow of its former self. Light colors pop with brilliance. Prima Amigo is your last step to perfection. Whether you are cleaning, glazing or polishing, spend some time with Amigo and you will see why we think it will be your new best friend."

IMPRESSIONS

- Prima Amigo is a polymer product which is very dark in color. It is almost black. Smell was decent - it did enhance the experience.

- It fills - It is supposed to cover swirls while cleaning the paint in preparation for a sealant or wax. It does fill like crazy! Not that there were swirls on my paint but I also tried it on a pearl blue mini-van.

- It darkens - It covered a-lot, but it also muted the metalic in the dark blue way to much. On my black paint it looked good. Good enough, I am happy to use it on the rest of the car in the coming days.

- It is slick - After wipping the product off it left a slick sealant feel to the paint.

Only negative is that it did leave behind some texture. Like that of a cheap sealant. Pinnacle Paint Cleansing Lotion had much more clarity.

COMPARISONS

Smell

Mother’s Pre-Wax Cleaner had my favorite smell followed by Amigo. Pinnacle is very chemically and so is Mother’s Reflections (not the Top Coat). Pinnacle comes in last in the smell.

Filling

Amigo gets the prize followed by Mother’s Reflections. I chose to add Reflections to the comparison because it is a polymer cleaner like Amigo. I say Pinnacle filled the least but that can be a good thing.

Ease-of-Use

Pinnacle seemed to be the easiest to apply followed by Reflections. Amigo came in third. As far as removal Amigo came in second topped only by Reflections.

The Look

1st - Pinnacle
2nd - Amigo (only because of the texture)
3rd - Pre-Wax Cleaner - it did a great job but left a cheap filler on the paint that lightened the black.
4th - Reflections - It created too much of a mirror-like finish. I don’t want my black paint to be a reflective mirror! Instead I want it to be a deep dark pool of wetness.

Overall Quality

*Pinnacle wins. I like the clean, very smooth finish it left. The paint felt kind of sticky - very ready for an LSP. Amigo left a polymer behind that was sealant quality.

Prima 3.jpg
(If you look carefully at the garage roof-line in the reflection, you will notice quite a bit of texture. Personally, I like some of this softness yet it was a little too much in this test.)

FINAL IMPRESSIONS

Amigo does just what I need it to do, but I will reserve it for a time when there are some more flaws on the paint. I will use Pinnacle on the whole car this time. Amigo's claimed correcting ability will be needed soon (no doubt) when the paint is a little more degraded. My next full correction will probably be in June. I will probably use Amigo to buy some time sometime before the next full correction.

NOTES

- I could not capture the subtle differences on camera. Sorry, that there are not photo side-by-sides of the results.
* - Prima Amigo and Mother’s Pre-Wax cleaner claim to have some abrasives. I did not get impressions on the abilities of these products to correct. I am almost positive Amigo would win out big time. A more apples-to-apples would be comparing Amigo to the similar XMT 360 from Pinnacle or Blackfire's Total Polish & Seal neither of which I own.
- All products were applied by hand.
- Thank you to those who have reviewed this product in the past. It made great reading and I respect your opinions.
- Have you tried it? What have been your opinions and the impressions of the product?

Happy Detailing!
 

Attachments

  • AmigoImpressions1.jpg
    AmigoImpressions1.jpg
    107.4 KB · Views: 14
  • Amigo Impressions 2.jpg
    Amigo Impressions 2.jpg
    51.1 KB · Views: 17
  • Amigo Impressions 3.jpg
    Amigo Impressions 3.jpg
    86.8 KB · Views: 16
Thanks for the review. Amigo is my favorite cleaner/glaze. I find it better than most dedicated paint cleaners and glazes.
 
Great review !! Finally a good comparison review for Amigo compared to other products!!

I would have been interested to see how Poorboy's Pro Polish did in comparison. It also has some correction ability but I have personally never used it as such.
 
Great review. I do have a question though. I won a Pinnacle package one time, and the Paintwork Cleanser was in it. I've never used it because I couldn't really figure out where it would fit into my routine. Did you use it with a machine, and if so which pad does it work best with? I've obviously not put much thought into using it until now, but from your review it sounds like its worth trying since I already have it.
 
Great review. I do have a question though. I won a Pinnacle package one time, and the Paintwork Cleanser was in it. I've never used it because I couldn't really figure out where it would fit into my routine. Did you use it with a machine, and if so which pad does it work best with? I've obviously not put much thought into using it until now, but from your review it sounds like its worth trying since I already have it.

Mr. Clean, I only do this as a hobby so I digress to other men & women who have much more varied experience with Pinnacle's Paint Cleansing Lotion. Having said that, I am happy to give you my opinion and personal habit of using it.

I use it when my paint is in good shape That is, when I do not need to correct any moderately light to medium swirls. Also, when my "naked" paint is still jeweled enough to my taste. If not, I do a light polish.

My second criteria for using it is when I want to put a coat of of my LSD (no cleaning abilities for maximum shine!) but the paint is not clean enough to do so outright. In other words, when a topping just won't do.

I have never used it with my DA, although if I was in the business as you are I am sure I would want to.

What does everyone else think?

PS - Forgive the type-o's. I'm replying on an iPad.
 
I haven't used Amigo in a while but I remember really liking it. I used it on white (strange I know) with Blackfire Wet Diamond wax over the top. I found it really easy to use and it really added life to my white paint.
 
David,

Another clear concise easy to read review. :bigups

Product reviews are a necessity in determining whether or not one may wish to try a product. When you combine a review with other products raises the bar and forces it to compete with the competition....:bigups

Awesome reviews!! :yourrock
 
Great review David, I applaud you in the amount of time it took to do this and then put it all together. As others have said it's very informative to see products used in comparison reviews and very nice of you to take the time to help somebody else make an informed decision on where to spend their money.. :rockon

You asked for opinions and I'm going to tip toe on this because I sure don't want to take anything away from all your hard work. The only thing is though, and I know this can be hard with all the products out there, but they need to be the companies current product or comparable product..

Anyway here goes. Case in point the Mothers products used aren't what is current or in one of them in a different class. Mothers Pre Wax Cleaner has been replace by Pure Polish in a three step system that is used in part in what your wanting to achieve. Step 1 can be replaced by step 2 if not needed or you can go straight to step 3 if neither 1 or 2 are needed first. The Reflections is classified as an AIO almost a paint sealant with waxes and polymers in it which none of the comparables have which would give you a different end result which you found.

https://store.mothers.com/product_info.php?products_id=44&cPath=1

https://store.mothers.com/product_info.php?products_id=32&cPath=3
 
Great review David, I applaud you in the amount of time it took to do this and then put it all together. As others have said it's very informative to see products used in comparison reviews and very nice of you to take the time to help somebody else make an informed decision on where to spend their money.. :rockon

You asked for opinions and I'm going to tip toe on this because I sure don't want to take anything away from all your hard work. The only thing is though, and I know this can be hard with all the products out there, but they need to be the companies current product or comparable product..

Anyway here goes. Case in point the Mothers products used aren't what is current or in one of them in a different class. Mothers Pre Wax Cleaner has been replace by Pure Polish in a three step system that is used in part in what your wanting to achieve. Step 1 can be replaced by step 2 if not needed or you can go straight to step 3 if neither 1 or 2 are needed first. The Reflections is classified as an AIO almost a paint sealant with waxes and polymers in it which none of the comparables have which would give you a different end result which you found.

https://store.mothers.com/product_info.php?products_id=44&cPath=1

https://store.mothers.com/product_info.php?products_id=32&cPath=3

Thank you friend! No offense taken. I appreciate your perspective!

Interesting, I have never heard that Power Polish replaced Mothers Step 1. My understanding is that it was for machine ("power") only being it's advertised cut is only in direct proportion to the pad it is used with.

At the end of e day, these comparisons were not necessarily for the purpose of determining a superior product, but instead in understanding a new product in comparison to what I already know. Each product has its place and use.

By the way, in my opinion, Mother's #2 Sealant & Glaze topped over pre-wax cleaner does produce great results! It makes paint (especially black) really ready for an LSP.
 
Thank you friend! No offense taken. I appreciate your perspective!

Interesting, I have never heard that Power Polish replaced Mothers Step 1. My understanding is that it was for machine ("power") only being it's advertised cut is only in direct proportion to the pad it is used with.

At the end of e day, these comparisons were not necessarily for the purpose of determining a superior product, but instead in understanding a new product in comparison to what I already know. Each product has its place and use.

By the way, in my opinion, Mother's #2 Sealant & Glaze topped over pre-wax cleaner does produce great results! It makes paint (especially black) really ready for an LSP.

According to the Mothers website it is a name change only. Formula is the same.
2012 Product Catalog Online and Exciting SEMA Show Coverage - Wax Forum

Just realized you said Power Polish. That is the same - meant for machine application.
The Prewax Cleanser has been renamed Pure Polish. Sealer and Glaze Has been renamed Micro-Polishing Glaze.
 
Last edited:
Thanks for the review. I have been wanting to get my hands on some Amigo to try, but for some reason I didn't think it was machine friendly. Anyone have good experiences using this with a DA? What speed and pad were used?
 
depends on the paint but most AIO's are used with a polishing pad on speed 5

I'm going to try it with a grey pad first on some light marring for my spring detail.
 
The Look

1st - Pinnacle
2nd - Amigo (only because of the texture)
3rd - Pre-Wax Cleaner - it did a great job but left a cheap filler on the paint that lightened the black.
4th - Reflections - It created too much of a mirror-like finish. I don’t want my black paint to be a reflective mirror! Instead I want it to be a deep dark pool of wetness.

I have used Mothers Pre-Wax Cleaner a lot but do not understand your comment about filling to the extent it lightened the paint. Can you elaborate?
 
I have used Mothers Pre-Wax Cleaner a lot but do not understand your comment about filling to the extent it lightened the paint. Can you elaborate?

All I can say is that my experience was that it lightened the look on my black. One would think that as the clear coat got cleaner, the black would be darker. So, my conclusion was that it left something on the paint that was brighter causing the black to look lighter. I did not experience this with the other products. This is the opposite of Mother's Step 2 by the way. That product nicely darkens as it glazes.
 
Back
Top