problem with 4runner rear side markers

[timbowman1]

Hey guys, i broke yet another of my car's parts and need it to get replaced before i can drive. After going on a quest, i ended up with these two results. Which would be the smartest decision?



2004 Toyota 4Runner Rear Side Markers # TO1184101 @ GetAllParts.com



03 - 05 Toyota 4Runner Rear Bumper Reflector - Left (Driver) 04



Thanks!