while i have'nt tried any of the above wheel well dressings i'm sure they're all good. i know alot of you are gonna get a charge out of this but it really works well for me, no pun intended, i use, now get ready, liquid gold, yeah i know the stuff you use on wood cabinets and paneling. my brother turned me on to it and i thought he was well you know, but i gave it a try, i sprayed it and spread it on with a, what looks like a feather duster but has these long fibers on it, i got it in dollar tree, it's about 15" long and fits perfectly between the wheel and well, hey give it a try, i think it makes the well black and satin finish, but hey that's just me.