Natty's blue vs P21S

[rjom]

I have a container of Natty's blue that I layer 3 times, every 6 weeks or so. I have quite a bit left, I was thinking of trying some P21S 100% since I have read good things about it. I have a black metallic finish. Is there a noticeable difference between the Natty's blue and P21S that would make it worth spending $50? Or should I just be content using up my Natty's blue. I also use FK425 over the Natty's which I find to leave an incredible slickness and shine. Help me save, or make me spend. Thanks.

 

[Caprice270]

P21s100 does a great job on my Caprice. I highly recommend it. P21S concours wax has virtually the same look though for less money.

 

[mblgjr]

P21S will have a softer; warmer look compared to the Natty's. Natty's will have sharper; crisper reflections and be generally "brighter" looking.

 

[Evenflow]

P21S will have a softer; warmer look compared to the Natty's. Natty's will have sharper; crisper reflections and be generally "brighter" looking.

Complete opposite for me. Natty's Blue has always left me with a deep, wet look.

 

[drew.haynes]

Yeah I was thinking the opposite also. I would have thought of P21S being more crisp than deep/warm.

 

[gamby]

P21S will have a softer; warmer look compared to the Natty's. Natty's will have sharper; crisper reflections and be generally "brighter" looking.

Complete opposite for me. Natty's Blue has always left me with a deep, wet look.

So basically, both work excellently and results are subjective.



(much like most people's specific systems of choice)

 

[Legacy]

If 50 bucks is not going to break the bank, then go for it. Only way to see for yourself.

 

[Cassman]

If 50 bucks is not going to break the bank, then go for it. Only way to see for yourself.

I'd spend my $50 on something else. Most of the look is in the prep anyway.

 

[VroomVroom]

Definitely subjective. I have both and greatly prefer NB - agreeing with the folks that find it very wet with a lot of depth. P21S - no knock against it - just really doesn't do it for me.



Go with your gut, but I'd probably spend the money on a few other products - maybe a good AIO or separate cleansers and/or chemical polishes to really prep the finish in advance of the wax.

 

[jbone]

From what ive read around here it may be worth spending that $50 on some of Jeff Werkstat's product. You can get a nice kit for $50.

 

[trodd69]

Jus a quickie but at Car Detailing Supplies, Car Wax, Car Polishers, Car Care Products the P21S carnauba wax is priced @ $33.99, I'm not sure if you mean the Nattys is $50 or the P21S but if you're running out of the Nattys why not try the next brand and decide how it suits your own tastes/paint/environment? It's the only way for you to know really - we all have our own little foibles!

 

[rjom]

Thanks all. Spent my $50 on ONR and OID... keeping the Natty B.