CBlack said:
For reference, how would they do that? Sand down to metal and start from there (body shop)?
They can probably avoid such drastic measures unless the damage is quite severe.
Properly done, a touch up is just:
-clean out the chipped area
-apply basecoat paint
-apply clearcoat until touchup is higher than surrounding paint
-level touchup relative to surrounding paint via sanding
-compound out sanding marks
-polish out compounding marks
It's doing the above properly that's the trick
Welcome to Autopia! Hope you get this resolved.
Note that shoddy work is often disguised via "glazes", products that conceal scratches/etc. for a short time. The assumption is that you'll think things are OK, go away, and then not bother them again. To check that they didn't do this, you can try the following:
-buy a *VERY* soft microfiber towel and some rubbing alcohol
-dampen the MF towel with the alcohol and wipe the touched up area (the alcohol will clean off any glaze)
-inspect in good lighting
-ask how they plan to redo the job right
-maybe even tell 'em you want a different "truly new and undamaged" car
Good luck with this, many dealerships are, uhm...underhanded (to put it politely) and I hope yours isn't like that.