My Silver 99 Eclipse's bumpers didn't match either. After my accident, the front end got resprayed. Then, mysteriously it matched. My friend, who's a body/paint guy, told me that some manufacturers tint the paint differently on plastic bumpers because of the difference in color between the metal body panels and the urethane of the bumpers. Thinking about it, I could almost buy that. Different color primers affect the way that the paint on top of them looks, so I guess that different colored materials could affect the exact coloration of the primer. Either that or the flex-agent (this is my thought, not his, btw), but I really would think that the flex-agent is clear. Anyone from a body shop wanna chime in?